In employment discrimination and retaliation cases, courts have long used the McDonnell Douglas framework at summary judgment, but parties wanting to overturn the framework have recently and frequently asked the United States Supreme Court to reconsider the framework. The Supreme Court just rejected another attempt in Cross v. Central Contra Costa Transit Authority.
The McDonnell Douglas framework intends to give courts a consistent method to evaluate claims of intentional discrimination when direct evidence of such discrimination does not exist. Generally, the framework works like this:
- Plaintiffs must establish a prima facie case of discrimination, generally by showing they are a member of a protected class, they were qualified for their position, they experienced an adverse action, and a connection exists between their protected class and the adverse action.
- Defendants must provide a non-discriminatory reason for the adverse action.
- Plaintiffs must establish whether the defendants' non-discriminatory reason is pretext for discrimination.
Even though Justice Thomas wrote 2025 dissents questioning the McDonnell Douglas framework—and Justice Gorsuch joined one of those two dissents—other Justices apparently are uninterested in revisiting the framework now.
We'll monitor similar petitions to understand if the Supreme Court continues to support the framework or is only waiting for what it believes is a better opportunity to question the framework. For now, employers will use the framework to show courts why claims of indirect discrimination and retaliation cannot survive summary judgment.



